Eaton Street Seafood Market: Fresh Seafood Fare in Key West

Good value and good amount of lobster for the price of the roll. I thought it was very fresh but honestly, nothing insane in regard to flavor. We tried both kinds of lobster roll (hot and cold) and my kid got the fried fish. The fries were amazing, the fish was okay, slightly fishy in flavor. The rolls came with plantain chips and coleslaw. Some of the best coleslaw I've had! I just wish the rolls had a little more flavor or seasoning.

We came here as we weren't super hungry (as we knew we could get small stuff or share) and now I'm kind of wishing we came here when we were really hungry. We found street parking on the same block and the inside is truly a market. All of the seating is outdoors and even though it wasn't crowded as we came right before closing, we still waited for a table, but got one before our food arrived. We got the conch ceviche, which was amazing! It had huge chunks of conch and the citrus was not over powering. Also came with a ton of chips. We also got a bowl of the stone crab chowder. This was a lite chowder and wasn't too creamy, which I loved. Lastly, we got the scallops. They were cooked to perfection and the choice of two sides made this a great value. Four of us shared those items and it was the perfect meal!

I love this seafood market and visit every time I go to KW. It's so fresh and the stone crabs beat Joe's in Miami. The scallops are also super fresh and grilled to perfection. Check it out for casual and fresh seafood!

Seafood market with a kitchen. All the seafood looks delicious and their kitchen knocks it out of the park. We went one day and shared shrimp, it was blackened and had such a crispness to it. The rice is perfectly seasoned and the veggies are good. The fresh blackened mahi was so hearty and not overly salted. Seating is small and outdoors only. May have to share a table but it truly is delicious. This will stay a staple during all our visits!

Fresh fish, 2 for 1 drinks! Food was good. Oysters sub par but the rest of the platter was amazing!!! Enjoyed our lunch here! Service was great. Out on the patio deck upstairs was nice to people watch down below fun. It's a nice restaurant and we really enjoyed relaxing after a long walk around town.

Not a fancy restaurant, no reservations required you eat on picnic tables outside on paper plates. But when you take your first bite of this fresh fish your mind will wander as it feels like it was just caught a few minutes ago. We opted for grilled yet you can get blackened . You also get two sides . The onion rings were fresh but a bit greasy yellow rice could use a bit of seasoning but the fish is fresh and seasoned perfect . A great place to get fresh seafood . Meals are served quickly and service was friendly .

Must try: crab cake sandwich. I haven't tried a crab cake this good. You can taste the majority of the ingredients is real crab and very little "other ingredients" Conch fritters: fresh, hot and tasty

I spent almost $100 on my meal. Stone crab were sweet and very fresh. Kiddo didn't eat it with the key lime mustard but I did and it was a nice addition. Lobster roll was plentiful. Also fresh and large chunks of lobster. Grilled roll was buttery and well grilled. I prefer my lobster roll to be warm with butter and a slap of mayo on the bread but I'm glad I tried this. For the fish they recommended yellowtail snapper. I asked for it to be fried but wish I could've also tried blackened. It was beautiful. I didn't even eat the taco part just the fish dipped in that key lime mustard. Well fried, fresh, no fishy taste, no oily taste. It was so lovely. Service was very patient and friendly. Thank you for being open on Thanksgiving Day. You were one of the best parts of Key West.

little spot but really good. you can choose thr exact fish you want in yoir tacos. they taste really good and fresh. service was awesome and patiently wait for cuatomer to pixk their fish and also give good recommendations. the place is clean and feel comfortable. will definitely stop by on my next trip to the keys